Caseys General Stores (CASY) executive compensation, 2025 proxy

Darren M. Rebelez, President and Chief Executive Officer, was paid $10.7M in 2025, up 1% from $10.6M the year before. The CEO-to-median-employee pay ratio was 589:1, on median employee pay of $18,148.

Filed
July 23, 2025
Annual meeting
September 3, 2025
Pay year
2025
Named executives
5
CEO total pay
$10.7M+1% vs prior year
CEO to median employee
589:1median $18,148
CEO pay in equity
69%$7.3M in awards
Prior say-on-pay support
98%of votes cast
CEO at-risk pay
89%Target direct compensation mix
Other NEO at-risk pay
76%Average target direct mix
AIP payout
109%Of target
LTIP payout
250%FY23-FY25 performance period

How Rebelez was paid

$10.7M in total for 2025, as reported in the Summary Compensation Table. Equity awards are valued at grant, not at what they turned out to be worth.

Salary11%Stock awards69%Non-equity incentive18%All other compensation2%

Named executive officers

ExecutiveTotal
Darren M. RebelezPresident and Chief Executive Officer$10,680,190
Stephen P. Bramlage, Jr.Chief Financial Officer$3,651,539
Ena WilliamsChief Operating Officer$3,816,869
Thomas P. BrennanChief Merchandising Officer$2,345,799
Chad M. FrazellChief Human Resources Officer$2,071,944

What changed and why

  • $1.2B109% AIP payout followed exceptional fiscal 2025 financial performance, including record EBITDA of $1.2 billion.
  • 250%250% FY23-FY25 LTIP payout resulted from 200% ROIC and EBITDA PSU vesting plus the 25% TSR modifier.
  • 89%89% of CEO target direct compensation was at risk, compared with 76% for other NEOs on average.
  • 60%AIP metrics were weighted 60% EBITDA and 40% same-store sales growth for inside sales.
  • 97.9%2024 say-on-pay support was 97.9%, and the fiscal 2025 pay program was substantially unchanged.
  • No guaranteed incentive payments or uncapped incentive compensation opportunities were provided.

Other Caseys General Stores proxy statements

  • 2026 proxy statement

    Darren M. Rebelez paid $14.7M (+38% on the year), pay ratio 735:1.

    Filed Jul 22, 2026

About this page

Figures are automated and can be wrong; check the filing for the exact numbers. Totals follow SEC rules, which value stock and option awards at grant. Read the DEF 14A proxy statement for footnotes and the compensation committee's full reasoning.